Renowned author George R.R. Martin, the mind behind the epic fantasy series A Song of Ice and Fire, which inspired the blockbuster TV series Game of Thrones, continues to intrigue and frustrate fans with the lengthy delay of his upcoming novel, The Winds of Winter. Having started the draft around 2010, the book remains a work in progress more than a decade later.
Unlike many authors who rely on detailed outlines to guide their writing process, Martin has openly criticized this method, preferring instead a more organic development of his story. This approach, while unique, may be the very reason why fans are still waiting.
Why George R.R. Martin Dislikes Outlines
During an interview at the Library of Congress: National Book Festival, Martin expressed his disdain for formal outlines, stating, “I don’t have a formal outline. I’m not one of these writers who outlines every—what’s gonna be in every scene, what’s gonna be in every chapter. I might be faster if I did.” His reluctance to use this conventional tool stems from his past experiences as a scriptwriter, where outlining made him feel as if he was narrating the story twice, thus stripping the process of its spontaneity.
This sentiment was further echoed in his communications, such as his blog and interviews, where Martin revealed the struggle of balancing his numerous film and television commitments with his writing. Despite producing “some new pages” as recently as last September, the author has voiced concerns over ever completing The Winds of Winter, though he insists it remains a priority.
The Gardener Versus the Architect
Martin’s analogy of the “gardener” versus the “architect” writer describes his method well. He views his stories as living entities that evolve naturally, a process he finds crucial for creativity. This starkly contrasts with writers who meticulously plan every detail, akin to architects constructing buildings.
“The stories grow and evolve and change as I write them,” Martin has said. This might explain why The Winds of Winter has seen such extensive delays. Without a clear outline, the narrative’s direction is less predictable and potentially more susceptible to changes that require significant rewrites.
The Consequences of a Free-Form Writing Style
While Martin’s style allows for creative freedom, it also comes with notable drawbacks. Human memory is fallible, and without a written record, maintaining continuity and plot consistency over such a long-spanning saga becomes a formidable challenge. This is particularly pertinent for Martin, whose intricate plots and multitude of characters demand meticulous attention to detail.
Moreover, Martin’s approach highlights a broader debate within the writing community about the effectiveness of outlines. Proponents argue that outlines enhance productivity and coherence, while detractors like Martin believe they inhibit creativity.
Looking Ahead: Will ‘The Winds of Winter’ Ever Be Finished?
As the wait for The Winds of Winter continues, fans and critics alike speculate on when, or indeed if, Martin will conclude his magnum opus. His commitment to a natural, evolving story process, while frustrating for those eager for the next chapter, remains a testament to his artistic integrity. Whether this will ultimately satisfy the legions of fans who have been waiting since the early 2010s remains to be seen.
In the end, Martin’s legacy may be defined not just by the worlds he has created, but by his philosophical approach to writing, challenging the norms and expectations of the literary world. As the journey continues, so too does the anticipation for the next unexpected twist in the saga of Westeros.