Why Blake Lively’s ‘It Ends With Us’ Movie Misses a Key Emotional Punch From the Book

When Blake Lively stepped into the shoes of Lily in the cinematic adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s “It Ends With Us,” audiences flocked to theaters, eager to see the novel’s poignant narrative unfold on the big screen. The film, which has quickly become a box office success, aims to mirror the novel’s deep emotional resonance, yet some fans of the book may notice a significant element missing—Lily’s peculiar connection with Ellen DeGeneres, which played a vital role in deepening the layers of the character Atlas, portrayed by Brandon Sklenar.

Why Blake Lively’s ‘It Ends With Us’ Movie Misses a Key Emotional Punch From the Book
Blake Lively’s Film Falls Short

The Crucial Role of Ellen DeGeneres in Lily’s Life

In Hoover’s novel, Lily’s diary entries are distinctively addressed to Ellen DeGeneres, highlighting a unique obsession that adds depth to her character and her relationship dynamics. One of the novel’s pivotal moments involves Lily inviting Atlas to watch “The Ellen DeGeneres Show,” a shared experience that strengthens their bond. This culminates in a touching gesture where Atlas secures a memento from the TV host for Lily, symbolizing his profound affection. However, this meaningful subplot is conspicuously absent in the film adaptation, leaving a void in Atlas’s character development.

Impact of Excluding Ellen DeGeneres from the Film

The decision to omit DeGeneres from the film could be attributed to the recent controversies surrounding her, potentially affecting the movie’s reception. Nevertheless, this exclusion does more than just streamline the plot—it strips away a layer of Atlas’s character that could have offered audiences a richer understanding of his motivations and the depth of his relationship with Lily.

Why Blake Lively’s ‘It Ends With Us’ Movie Misses a Key Emotional Punch From the Book
Missing Emotional Depth Explored

Brandon Sklenar Addresses Rumors and Defends the Film’s Integrity

Amidst the film’s release, co-star Brandon Sklenar has been vocal in dispelling rumors, particularly regarding alleged tensions between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni. Sklenar emphasizes the film’s core message of empowerment and resilience, particularly resonant for survivors of domestic abuse. By addressing these rumors, Sklenar reinforces the film’s purpose and the importance of positivity in its reception.

“It just seems silly to me. It’s kinda defeating the whole purpose of the thing to spread any negativity. It’s an important film for so many women and for so many survivors of domestic abuse. And yeah, that’s what it’s all about, is making people feel heard and strong and loved. So to project anything but that seems counterintuitive. And I appreciate those people that appreciated it,” Sklenar stated, highlighting the film’s deeper significance beyond its narrative.

Why Blake Lively’s ‘It Ends With Us’ Movie Misses a Key Emotional Punch From the Book
Book vs. Movie Discrepancies

A Missed Opportunity for Character Enhancement

While “It Ends With Us” continues to captivate audiences with its compelling portrayal of challenging themes, the film adaptation’s deviation from the novel’s original script—especially the exclusion of Ellen DeGeneres—serves as a poignant reminder of what could have been. This alteration not only affects the portrayal of Atlas but also shifts the overall dynamic presented in the book. As the film runs in theaters, it stands as a testament to the complexities involved in adapting beloved novels, where certain depths can sometimes be lost in translation.

Leave a Comment