Elizabeth Olsen’s rise to stardom didn’t happen overnight, but the decisions she made along the way certainly shaped the trajectory of her career. From indie films to the heart of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), one of the pivotal moments in her journey came when she turned down a favorite project to join the MCU in Avengers: Age of Ultron. This career-defining choice became a major turning point, and now, as Olsen explores new genres, her time in the MCU continues to influence her path forward.
From Indie Darling to Marvel’s Scarlet Witch
Before becoming the powerful Scarlet Witch, Elizabeth Olsen was making a name for herself in the world of independent films. Best known initially as the younger sister of famous twins Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen, Elizabeth was determined to carve out her own identity in Hollywood. She did just that, starring in critically acclaimed indie films like Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011) and Silent House (2011).
Her shift into mainstream cinema began with roles in movies like Godzilla (2014), but it was her role as Wanda Maximoff in Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015) that catapulted her to international fame. It wasn’t just a role—it was a commitment, one that shaped the next seven years of her career.
The Movie That “Sucked” to Lose
In a candid interview with Dazed, Olsen opened up about a significant sacrifice she made early in her MCU tenure. Prior to being cast as Wanda Maximoff, she was attached to The Lobster, a dark, dystopian satire directed by Yorgos Lanthimos. The script had quickly become one of her favorites, and the opportunity to work with Lanthimos was a dream. Unfortunately, the scheduling conflicts with Marvel meant that Olsen had to let it go.
“That sucked. That was one of my favorite scripts I ever read,”
Olsen admitted in her interview. The Age of Ultron contract required her full commitment, making it impossible to pursue the Lanthimos project. The role in The Lobster eventually went to Rachel Weisz, but for Olsen, the decision was bittersweet. While the Marvel role launched her to new heights, it was hard to let go of a project she was passionate about.
The Long Road as Wanda Maximoff
Olsen went on to reprise the role of Wanda Maximoff in five more Marvel films and the hit Disney+ series WandaVision. As the character evolved into the Scarlet Witch, Olsen’s portrayal became a fan favorite, and her performance in WandaVision garnered critical acclaim. Yet, with each passing Marvel project, the question of what could have been—had she pursued other projects like The Lobster—lingered.
The seven-year journey as Wanda was a demanding one, both in terms of time and the sheer scale of Marvel’s filmmaking process. But for Olsen, this commitment paid off in more ways than one. It helped her escape the shadow of her famous sisters and gave her a platform few other actors could dream of. However, it also limited her ability to explore other creative avenues.
“I Wouldn’t Be Where I Am Without Marvel”
In reflecting on her Marvel experience, Olsen has expressed a complex mix of gratitude and reflection. While it’s clear she recognizes the opportunity Marvel provided, there’s also an acknowledgment of the cost. In her own words, had she passed on Avengers: Age of Ultron, she might still be living in the shadow of her siblings, and her career could look very different today.
Olsen told Collider that she’s not opposed to returning to the MCU if her character is used well, adding, “If there’s a good story to tell, I’m happy to come back.”
Her future with Marvel remains uncertain, but for now, it seems Olsen is ready to explore roles outside the superhero realm.
What’s Next for Elizabeth Olsen?
As Olsen moves forward, she’s returning to her indie roots with upcoming films that promise to showcase her versatility as an actor. Her latest project, His Three Daughters, directed by Azazel Jacobs, is a stark contrast to the big-budget superhero films she’s known for. This Netflix production brings Olsen back to a more grounded, character-driven story—something she seems eager to embrace again.
Additionally, she’s set to star in Love Child, a film by Todd Solondz that explores dark family dynamics, further proof that Olsen is choosing projects that speak to her strengths as an actor. It’s clear that after her Marvel years, Olsen is making conscious decisions to engage with diverse roles, allowing her to demonstrate her full range as a performer.
A New Era for Elizabeth Olsen
Elizabeth Olsen’s Marvel journey may have required sacrifice, but it’s also the reason she’s now in a position to pick and choose the projects she’s passionate about. From losing her dream role in The Lobster to dominating screens as Wanda Maximoff, Olsen’s story is one of resilience and professional growth. As she embarks on this new chapter in her career, it’s clear she’s ready to embrace whatever comes next.
Her decision to step away from the MCU and venture into different genres is a reflection of her desire to evolve as an artist. Whether she returns to Marvel or not, her influence in the entertainment industry is undeniable. For now, fans can look forward to seeing her shine in more intimate and unconventional roles, a testament to her ever-growing talent.