How Andy Mientus Almost Became The Flash Before His Breakout Role as Arrowverse’s First Gay Villain

In the kaleidoscopic world of the DC Universe, where superheroes like Batman and Superman reign supreme, one character has raced to the forefront with electrifying speed—The Flash. Yet, behind the scenes, a different tale was unfolding—one that could have dramatically altered the landscape of the Arrowverse. This is the story of Andy Mientus, an actor known for his role as the world’s first openly gay supervillain, who nearly donned the scarlet suit of The Flash before making his mark as the infamous Pied Piper.

How Andy Mientus Almost Became The Flash Before His Breakout Role as Arrowverse's First Gay Villain
Andy Mientus’ Near-Flash Experience

A Near Miss with Destiny

Grant Gustin’s portrayal of Barry Allen, also known as The Flash, has captivated fans and critics alike, making him a definitive figure within the DC franchise. However, there was a moment when Gustin’s iconic role was nearly claimed by another. Andy Mientus, a name that resonates with Arrowverse fans for his chilling performance as Hartley Rathaway, the Pied Piper, had initially thrown his hat in the ring for the role of the fleet-footed hero.

I didn’t get very far along in the process of reading for Barry,” he admitted. Though he wasn’t the final choice for The Flash, the feedback he received was encouraging: “He’s not quite the right fit for Barry, but we really like him. He’s really interesting. Maybe there’s something down the pike.

The Call That Changed Everything

The journey of an actor is often marked by auditions and rejections, a sentiment Mientus knows all too well. Yet, his perseverance and resilience paid off when he received a call that would lead him to a role perfectly suited for him.

When they did call, my ears pricked up,

Mientus recalled. The character of Pied Piper not only offered him an exciting new challenge but also an opportunity to bring depth and complexity to a character that was both villainous and vibrant.
Upon receiving the script, Mientus felt an immediate connection.

How Andy Mientus Almost Became The Flash Before His Breakout Role as Arrowverse's First Gay Villain
Andy’s Arrowverse Casting Twist

When I read it, I saw that it was maybe a good fit for me, and I just really liked it. I immediately felt an attachment,

he shared. This attachment translated into a powerful portrayal that not only delighted viewers but also allowed Mientus to leave a lasting imprint on the series.

Becoming the Pied Piper

Stepping into the role of Pied Piper, Mientus brought to life a character that was as cunning as he was charismatic. His performance not only won him accolades but also helped redefine what it meant to be a villain in the superhero genre.

It was a character that I wanted to see and knew I would enjoy, as a viewer, so it was then somebody that I wanted to embody,

Mientus explained about his approach to the role.
His portrayal resonated with fans, turning Pied Piper into a character that viewers loved to hate and hated to love. Mientus’s commitment to the role showed through every scene, making Pied Piper a standout character in the Arrowverse and Mientus a household name among DC fans.

How Andy Mientus Almost Became The Flash Before His Breakout Role as Arrowverse's First Gay Villain
From Almost Flash to Villain

A Flash of What Could Have Been

While Andy Mientus did not end up playing The Flash, his journey through the Arrowverse is a testament to the unpredictable nature of casting in Hollywood. His story reminds us that sometimes, not getting what you initially want may lead to unexpected opportunities that resonate more profoundly with both the actor and the audience.
As fans of the Arrowverse, we witnessed not only the speed of The Flash but also the piercing sound of the Pied Piper, thanks to Andy Mientus’s remarkable flexibility and talent. His career trajectory in the DC Universe might have started with a missed opportunity, but it certainly landed him a role that showcased his dynamic abilities and helped expand the rich tapestry of characters within the Arrowverse.

Leave a Comment